Food

The Black Lives Matter movement is bigger than ever, and that means more scrutiny

It was July 2013 and George Zimmerman was on trial for murder in the killing of Trayvon Martin, a 17-year-old Black boy who had been walking in his father's Florida neighborhood. The night the verdict was set to be announced, Alicia Garza and some friends gathered for drinks.None of them thought Zimmerman would be acquitted on all charges. But that's what happened. And Garza felt like she'd been punched in the gut, she told MSNBC.That night Garza woke up in the middle of the night crying. So she began writing out how she felt, in an emotional Facebook post. She wrote that she continued to be surprised "at how little Black lives matter.""That's really what Black Lives Matter was for me," Garza told MSNBC. "And that's why I said Black people, I love you. I love us. And that our lives matter. And that we matter. And that Black lives matter."The phrase "Black lives matter" inspired Garza's friend, Patrisse Cullors, to create a hashtag. Almost instantly, it went viral. "I wanted it to go viral," Cullors, who co-founded Black Lives Matter with Garza and Opal Tometi,told CNN. "On July 15th, 2013 I said that Alicia and I had created a thing called #BlackLivesMatter and we hope that it will be bigger than we can ever imagine," Cullors said. "Over the last seven years we've developed more infrastructure and we've become more organized."Momentum around the movement has grown amid calls for justice following the deaths of Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor and George Floyd.The phrase "Black Lives Matter" is being used now as more than just a hashtag — it's a rallying cry. At protests, it's what many demonstrators write on their signs or chant as they march. Online, it's what many have used to spread the message against police brutality. And globally, it's being used by many to show solidarity with Black people.While many believe the movement is more accepted than it once was, others remain skeptical of what it accomplishes and question its impact.Here's what you need to know about the evolution of the movement, and why it matters.

Growth of a movement

Black Lives Matter is one of the most well-known organizations fighting for the well-being of Black people.Studies show that segregation persists in many American cities, leaving majority Black communities behind. BLM's goal, according to its website, is to eradicate anti-Blackness and create a society where Black people are able to thrive in the US. "We live in a country built to keep us away from these resources that we need," said Kailee Scales, managing director of the Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation. Scales referenced the data. Police officers are almost four times as likely to use force on Black people than White people. Black people are also jailed at a disproportionate rate. Black Americans have lower access to health care and lack the same access to quality education."Folks in the movement have been consistently fighting to reverse that trend, to raise awareness that this is not the way we're supposed to live," Scales told CNN.Since the hashtag launched, the organization has become more formalized, taken on specific branding and branched out into nationwide chapters — all in an attempt to solidify the group and allow them to create national campaigns while engaging the broader community.Organizers put together a website, which led to the development of local chapters of BLM, first in Los Angeles in 2013 and then throughout the country, according to Scales.Left to right, co-founders of BLM, Opal Tometi, Alicia Garza and Patrisse Cullors appear onstage during The New York Women's Foundation Celebrating Women Breakfast in 2015.After the protests in Ferguson, Missouri, against police brutality in 2014, the organization became more well known. In 2017 it became incorporated as the Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation, Inc.Today the network consists of 13 official chapters in the US, plus three more in Canada,according to the BLM website. Local chapters are semi-autonomous, meaning they "do the work that makes sense" for their communities, Scales said.The structure allows the group to have an impact at all levels — doing work both nationally and locally, she said. Each chapter works a little differently and has different focuses, depending on community needs. The Chicago chapter, for example, focuses more on police accountability, while the Boston chapter does a lot of activity around mutual aid, Scales said.Protests in Los Angeles, after the murder of George Floyd.In Los Angeles BLM activists have been at the forefront of the defund police movement, meeting with local politicians about a proposal they call the People's Budget, which would reallocate funding from the Los Angeles Police Department.The group has called for defunding the police for at least five years, Black Lives Matter Los Angeles co-founder Melina Abdullah told CNN. The most recent push began in May, and at the time the chapter had little support from local politicians.After George Floyd's killing, however, the group gained momentum and received some support from a few members of the Los Angeles City Council.In June, after pressure from BLMLA and massive protests, the council unanimously approved a measure to develop an unarmed model of crisis response that would replace police officers with community-based responders for nonviolent calls. Following the vote, City Councilmember Herb Wesson Jr., who authored the motion with Council President Nury Martinez, said in a tweet that he looks "forward to continuing this work alongside" BLMLA.And there is more work to be done, Abdullah said. "(We) never thought that that (amount) was anywhere near enough," she told CNN. "But it's a step forward that we forced."The different chapters are bound by a set of guiding principles, which work to ground the individual entities. But they also work together. Chapters tend to work across state lines, Abdullah told CNN. When the BLM chapter in South Bend, Indiana, was getting started,Abdullah said the group worked closely with BLMLA — specifically comparing notes on the terms of mayors Pete Buttigieg and Eric Garcetti. There's a growing call to defund the police. Here's what it meansIt's worth noting that not every protest or demonstration is part of the Black Lives Matter network, as some may be organized by people simply using the movement's name. And not every person attending a BLM protest is a part of their local BLM chapter. The movement is largely decentralized, with no one besides managing director Scales receiving pay, said Abdullah, who also works as a professor at California State University in Los Angeles.Chapters tend to have a loose leadership structure, with a focus on on-the-ground organizing — allowing chapters the autonomy to organize in the way they see fit. Until George Floyd's death, Abdullah said BLMLA had only raised $100,000 in the last seven years, money that it used for "the basic cost of organizing," things like renting rooms, making copies, printing banners and hiring unarmed security. They also try to provide limited support to families who lose members to police brutality, like aiding with funeral costs, which Abdullah said can sometimes run up to $20,000.And unless money is earmarked specifically for the local chapters, money donated through the main network goes to the larger global network, Abdullah said. Chapters can ask for a little money from the national organization, but it's not always a significant amount, she said.But with donations streaming in after Floyd's death, BLMLA has more money than it has ever had. "We're stepping back to take a minute and process what we should be doing with the newfound money that we've never had before," she said.

'All Lives Matter' and other backlash

With more notoriety comes more scrutiny, and the Black Lives Matter movement has experienced its fair share of criticism. Some have said while they support the movement's cause, they are not a fan of its approach, contrasting some of the protests today to the peaceful ones of the civil rights movement of the 1960s.Many have condemned the more progressive demands of the cause, most notably the call to defund the police, which would instead invest those funds in communities, especially marginalized ones where much of the policing occurs.Why saying 'All lives matter' misses the big pictureLike Abdullah said, the call to defund the police has been a key priority of the movement for years. But as these calls increase, police unions across the country have dug in to protect their own — even though the movement has support from organizations like Amnesty International and video evidence of officers using excessive force against protesters. And the notion still faces pushback from people on both sides of the political aisle. President Donald Trump has defended the police. Meanwhile, politicians like Gov. Tony Evers of Wisconsin, a Democrat, has said defunding goes too far. Others have called the movement too radical.In Arizona, Rep. Walt Blackman, a Black GOP member of the Arizona Legislature, labeled BLM a "terrorist organization" in an interview with Fox News Radio affiliate KFYI. He then told the Arizona Republic in a follow up interview that BLM is an "ideology that goes against the very concepts and precepts of our principles in the United States."Critics have also responded to the phrase "Black Lives Matter" by coining their own slogans, such as "All Lives Matter," which some argue minimizes the current struggle Black people face against systemic racism, and "Blue Lives Matter," referring to the lives of police.Trump previously called the words "Black Lives Matter" a "symbol of hate" in a tweet criticizing New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio for "denigrating" Fifth Avenue in Manhattanwith a BLM mural.Still, Michael Kazin, who studies social movements at Georgetown University, said it's surprising that the movement hasn't received more backlash. He said it's the first time in history that a movement focused on Black equality has seen this kind of support from White people."Even in the '60s, with the (March on Washington), polls at the time never had more than 15, 20% support among Whites," Kazin, who isalso theco-editor of the democratic-socialist publication Dissent Magazine, told CNN.There's been an outpouring of support from diverse populations, he said. He used Portland, Oregon, as an example, where federal officers have Read More – Source

Show More

Related Articles